The difference is who decides the length: you, or the foot.
Four-step buttonhole
You sew the buttonhole in four stages, turning the dial between each:
- One side.
- A bar tack across one end.
- The other side.
- A bar tack across the other end.
You decide where each side stops, usually by watching a mark on the fabric or the foot. It works well with careful marking, but sides of different lengths and uneven buttonholes are common at first.
One-step buttonhole
A special buttonhole foot holds the button in a slot at the back. You pull down a buttonhole lever and sew; the machine stitches the whole buttonhole, sized to the button, and stops. Every buttonhole on the garment comes out the same size.
Many beginner machines, such as the Brother XM2701, include one; computerized machines such as the CS7000X offer several styles — keyhole, rounded, stretch.
Which matters for you
For shirts, dresses and jackets with several buttons, a one-step buttonhole is a real advantage. For occasional buttonholes, a four-step works.
Preparation is the same
Whichever type:
- Interface the area — see how to apply fusible interfacing.
- Mark the buttonhole positions.
- Test on a scrap with the same layers.
Common problems
One-step stops partway: the lever was not pulled down, or the fabric dragged. Support the fabric and let the foot move freely.
Four-step sides uneven: mark the length clearly and count stitches for each side.
Puckering: no interfacing or a dull needle.
Tension
Buttonholes look best with a slightly looser top tension, so no bobbin thread shows on top. Many computerized machines adjust this automatically.
Cutting open
Pin across the end, then cut between the rows with a seam ripper.
Related
See what is a bar tack and our beginner sewing machines page.
What sewers ask us
Is a one-step buttonhole better?
For consistency and ease, yes. Every buttonhole matches the button and the others.
Can I sew good buttonholes with a four-step machine?
Yes, with marking and practice. Measure and mark each buttonhole's length carefully.
Why does my one-step buttonhole stop partway?
Often the buttonhole lever was not pulled down, or the fabric dragged so the foot could not move freely.
Do I need interfacing?
Yes, for both types, so the fabric does not stretch under the dense stitches.
Last reviewed