Skip to content

Brother FS40S vs Singer M1005

A screen, or a free arm and one fewer thing to break?

Both are light machines for alterations and light dressmaking. One is computerised, one is mechanical, and they differ on where they are sold.

Brother FS40S computerised sewing machine, front three-quarter view

Brother FS40S

Wins 2 of 6

Check price

≈ 200 €

Singer M1005, product photograph

Singer M1005

Wins 0 of 6

Check price

≈ 100 €

Line by line

Compared on FS40S M1005
Type Computerised Mechanical
Stitches 40 Not published
Free arm Yes Yes
Weight 2.95 kg Not published
Markets verified All six Five — not the US
Buttonhole Not published Semi-automatic (4-step)

A tick marks the better answer on that line only. Counting ticks does not decide the page — the two verdicts below do, because these machines answer different questions.

Which one, for whom

Buy the FS40S

Buy the Brother if you want stitch selection on a screen and the widest availability of any machine on this site. It is the lighter, more modern option.

Buy the M1005

Buy the Singer if you prefer mechanical simplicity and are in Europe. A four-step buttonhole asks more of you but there is less to fail.

Questions people actually ask

Is under three kilos too light?

It means a plastic frame, with the flex that implies. Fine for cotton and shirting, wrong for folded denim. Both machines are in that class.

Does the screen help a beginner?

A little — it removes guesswork about which stitch is selected. It is not the reason to choose computerised; a one-step buttonhole would be, and neither listing confirms one.

The full reviews

  • Brother FS40S

    40 stitches · LCD · free arm · 2.95 kg

    Brother's light computerised machine: 40 stitches, an LCD, a needle threader and a free arm, at just under three kilos. One reference on all six Amazon stores we checked.

    Best for: Light dressmaking, alterations and a first machine that has to live in a cupboard

    ≈ 200 €

  • Singer M1005

    Free arm · semi-automatic · compact

    A compact free-arm machine, available under one reference across all five European markets. The most widely available portable machine in our checks.

    Best for: Alterations, repairs and a machine that lives in a cupboard

    ≈ 100 €