Skip to content

Why is my buttonhole fraying or tearing?

A buttonhole frays when the fabric inside it is unsupported or the stitches are too open.

1. Interfacing

Interface the button band, or put a small piece of interfacing behind each buttonhole — see how to apply fusible interfacing.

2. Stitch density

On loose weaves, a slightly denser buttonhole — a shorter stitch length setting — covers the edges better.

3. Cutting

  • Put a pin across each end, just inside the bar tack.
  • Cut between the rows with a seam ripper or buttonhole cutter, from one end toward the pin.
  • Never cut through the bar tacks.

4. Seam sealant

A drop of seam sealant on the cut edges stops fraying. Test it on a scrap; some stiffen or discolor fabric.

5. Size

A buttonhole too short for the button strains and tears at the ends. Test with the actual button — see how to sew a buttonhole.

6. Fabric

Loose weaves, linen and fine fabrics fray most. Use a stabilizer and slightly denser stitches.

7. Corded buttonholes

Stitching over a fine cord reinforces the buttonhole and helps it keep its shape, especially on knits. Many buttonhole feet have a hook for the cord.

8. Needle and thread

A new needle and good thread give clean, dense stitches — see needle and thread pairing.

Repairing a frayed buttonhole

Stitch over it again with a narrow zigzag, or work buttonhole stitch over the edges by hand.

Test

Always sew a test buttonhole on the same layers first.

Placement

Buttonholes placed too close to the garment edge have little fabric around them and tear sooner. Follow the pattern’s markings, which leave room for the button.

Knits

On knits, a stretch or keyhole buttonhole and a stabilizer behind it help; the fabric otherwise stretches as you sew and the buttonhole gapes.

See one-step or four-step buttonhole.

What sewers ask us

Why does my buttonhole tear at the end?

The bar tack was cut, or the buttonhole is too short for the button and strains when buttoned.

Should I interface buttonholes?

Yes, always. Without it, the fabric stretches and frays.

What is seam sealant?

A liquid that stiffens and seals cut fibers. Test it on a scrap first.

What is a corded buttonhole?

A buttonhole stitched over a fine cord, which reinforces it and helps it keep its shape.

Last reviewed